@Michelle
I'm sure you have helped plenty of people but I realized you don't necessarily have general knowledge about the system as a whole. Getting a pardon doesn't erase a conviction. It simply sets it aside so it's not viewable to the public. It will no longer be found on CPIC but can be traced and uncovered using other methods.
There is another piece of legislation that allows anyone of higher authority, even journalists, to gain access to classified information including but not limited to criminal convictions that have been pardoned of individuals. Discharges, dropped charges, acquittals and peace bonds, although canadian law treats these differently, also are registered in the system and can be accessed through the Privacy Act.
Many journalists have a mandate to uncover as much as they can in order to protect the public however, someone's reputation can seriously be damaged on false accusations. What I am trying to say is that some people with evil intent can harm a person who happened to have a simple brush with the law. Is it really necessary to keep information for simple charges like theft or vandalism under 100$?
The US knows how canadian law works although CBP agents don't necessarily have to. The current administration is using politics of fear to steer Americans away from real issues within the country. It is also important to note that american officials routinely scroll through millions of website and can technically uncover so much about each one of us.
The current administration doesn't like criminals as they love to call them. It won't be long before a traffic violation will make every single Canadian inadmissible to the US.
At this rate, it's only fair for every Canadian to pay a flat fee for a visa to enter the US. No Canadian will pay exhorbatant rates as high as 1400$ US for a one year waiver. Ending free travel and imposing a rate of 25$/person for a VISA sounds reasonable. As for someone who committed a minor offence from 10 years ago, why keep punishing them?
It's the beginning of the end for free travel. We should all try to take advantage of it before each country begins following the US. Some already have including our very own, Canada.